Should I Talk to the Affair Partner?

Should you confront the affair partner? What are the reasons to do this? Should you tell their spouse about the affair? Does the unfaithful spouse owe an apology to the affair partner's (AP's) betrayed spouse?

As someone who went into these conversations motivated by vengeance, I am going to share my story and perspective on how you can approach these issues in your own situation.

You're not the only one wrestling with these types of questions. Explore Harboring Hope, a course for betrayed spouses where you can journey alongside other betrayed spouses towards healing

Sign Up | Harboring Hope

For betrayed spouses, the motivations can range from curious to vindictive:

  • You want answers to questions.
  • You want to reclaim power.
  • You want to set the record straight.
  • You feel confronting them will provide a sense of closure or relief from the pain.
  • You desire justice or vengeance.

All of these reasons are valid and understandable, but I am here to tell you:

Valid and understandable reasons do not necessarily mean these are wise decisions, nor will they make everything better.

I was motivated by all of the above, but particularly that last one. "Early-recovery Candace" was consumed by my desire for vengeance to be exacted and for justice to be served. So, how did that work out for me?

After months and months of going around and around with my therapist, she finally agreed I could text my husband's AP. I took her consent, raced to my phone, and sent a seething text message to the AP without my therapist blessing the content. This was an "early-recovery Candace" who was mad as hell. I felt like I had nothing to lose because I had already lost everything!

Here's the hard truth for betrayed spouses: If the AP knew your spouse was married and still participated, they've already rewritten their reality to justify their role in the affair.

They didn't have your best interest in mind then, so why would they now? It is much more likely they will resort to damage control, or even shaming, saying whatever they need to say to get themselves off the hook. If they're still emotionally attached, or hoping to stay in the relationship with your spouse, they may say things intended to sabotage and destroy what's left of your marriage. They will repeat the story they've told themselves, shaped by fantasy, rationalization, and self-protection.

If you're considering staying in your marriage, please, protect your space. You're trying to rebuild something extremely fragile, so don't let the AP's version of events become embedded in that new foundation. They do not know your spouse's true motives any more than you do.

Reaching out can also elevate the AP's significance in the story. The more attention you give them, the more space they take up in your healing. In terms of your recovery, they don't deserve center stage, you do. So what's the strongest, most self-honoring move? According to our Founder and President Rick Reynolds:

"Let silence speak for you."

When you refuse to engage, you send a louder message than any words ever could: You don't matter in my story anymore.

About that glaring text message I sent to the AP. There I stood in my walk-in closet, phone still in hand, heart pounding. Minutes became hours and hours bled into days. Once those days turned into a full week, it finally hit me: She's not going to respond.

The same woman who had the audacity to impersonate me (the real wife) didn't have the decency to acknowledge my text. Not even a single word. The silence was deafening. It felt like a second betrayal layered on top of the first, doubling the feelings of irrelevance that were suffocating me.

So, before you show up unannounced, make that call, or hit send on that text, ask yourself: What do I hope to gain by contacting them? Am I prepared for any answer or no answer at all? What will this do to my healing, my dignity, or my relationship if we're trying to reconcile? Will this invite more chaos, drama, or trauma into my life?

What about contacting the AP's spouse? Should you? Why would you?

  • You want to expose the affair.
  • You want to find additional information.
  • You're concerned for them.
  • You're looking for a friend who understands your pain.
  • Your life is ruined, and you want to ruin their life too.
  • You desire to engage in a revenge affair.

I believed I had righteous motives. I believed the AP's husband deserved the truth. If I were to sum up how that text went in one word: Dissatisfying.

After I sent the text, the other betrayed partner responded within minutes, agreeing to speak an hour later. I was finally getting my moment to strike back. I'd fantasized about this for months. It was my turn to throw a grenade into her life.

He answered the phone, we spoke, it was brief...It was disappointingly brief. He didn't want the full truth, not from me, anyway, and maybe not at all.

I'll never know what happened in that house the night I told the AP's husband about the affair his wife was having. What I do know is this: the grenade I had built up in my mind for so long? As far as I could tell, it failed to detonate. And for early-recovery Candace, a vengeful, desperate-for-justice Candace, that outcome was beyond disappointing.

What about an unfaithful spouse who wants to reach out to their AP's spouse?

  • You desire to clear a guilty conscience and make amends.
  • You're afraid of being unable to control their narrative.
  • You fear blackmail or retribution.
  • Your shame is driving you to throw yourself on the altar in front of the spouse as a sacrifice.

Wayward partners, while your intentions might feel honorable, the primary behavior that needs to be amended is your presence in their lives, so do the opposite of continuing to involve yourself and stay the heck out. You can't clear your conscience by inflicting new wounds on another and call it recovery.

Here's the reality: If the betrayed or the wayward spouse (or an extended family member or friend of either one) reaches out to the AP's spouse with information, a confession, or confrontation, no matter their motives, they are essentially setting off a bomb in another person's life, and that makes them an aggressor.

If you are thinking of reaching out to the AP on the other side, I implore you to consider these alternative actions:

  • Share your thoughts with a therapist or support group and be open to their feedback.
  • Direct your energy into creating boundaries or investing in your healing instead of obsessing over those other people.
  • Focus on the three recoveries that matter: yours, your spouse's and the marriage itself. The AP has no place in any of those.
  • If you are stuck in obsessive ruminating, our founder, Rick Reynolds, recommends writing out everything you wish to say in the form of a letter you never send.

No matter your position in the big messy equation, avoid acting out of panic, guilt, or the need for justice.

Vow to do no harm and act in alignment with the values you're now trying to live by — honesty, integrity, and respect for all those impacted. Only then will you find the closure and fulfillment you are after.

About three years after I sent that nasty text to my husband's AP, I was kayaking in Morro Bay in Central California with my husband and daughters. The sun was shining, the water was calm, and there were adorable little sea otters playing in the water around us. It was a peaceful day that took years for our family to find.

As I stepped out of the kayak, I fumbled my phone — and just like that, it slipped from my hand and plummeted 20 feet into the water below.

It could not be rescued.

My first thought wasn't about my credit card or driver's license that were unfortunately inside the phone case. It wasn't even about replacing the pricey phone. My very first thought was that I didn't have my text messages backed up to the cloud. I lost the only text I ever sent to the AP. That one message that carried my voice, my pain, my effort to restore my dignity, while trying to create a shame storm for her…it was gone.

One of our daughters opened our Life360 app and there it was. My phone, still alive in a waterproof case, was drifting further and further out to sea. I tracked it for hours from my computer until the battery died.

It wasn't until days later that I realized the symbolism of losing my phone.

That message wasn't quickly deleted. It drifted and sank slowly, silently, into the cold darkness. My connection to the AP had been released. It was a poetic ending.

The quiet letting go of a vengeful chapter of my life no longer needed to be carried in my pocket day after day. While it wasn't by choice, the tie was severed. I realized that watching the unanswered message (my phone) drift out to sea is the loudest, most powerful thing I could have done with it. As Rick says, "Let them go and get your life back."

Whether wayward or betrayed, if you're ready to truly let go and begin to reclaim your life, sign up for one of our courses today and take a bold step towards healing. If you're unsure of where to start, schedule a call with our team. We've been there; we get the pain and are here to help.

Add New Comment:

Comments

Contacting your spouse’s affair partner

I agree with your post, don’t do it! Please feel free to post this if it’s relevant!

I contacted my husband’s AP with good intentions: I wanted to know how serious they were before agreeing to work on our marriage:

1) They both lied to me. I have no idea why, I had told him he was free to leave & be with her if he wanted.

2) I unwittingly gave her my phone number. Setting myself up for months of malicious anonymous messages (which my ex denied was her!).

3) ultimately I had to change my phone number, call the police (who didn’t care, of course, but I wanted to tell her that I had done so) & block her.

4) I chose not to tell her spouse, as the proverb says “If you seek revenge better dig 2 graves”

5) I’m now on my way to a fairly amicable divorce. My ex has saddled himself with a psycho…good luck to him 😉

Thank you for sharing your

Thank you for sharing your experience with us, Laura. I'm so sorry you were lied to when all you wanted were answers so that you could make informed choices for yourself. You didn't deserve that. Praying all the best over you as you continue to heal.

So good and timely

I struggle with this so much! This was great information and very helpful. I definitely picture it resulting in me getting vindication while hurting her, but this made me see it more realistically and rationally. The feelings of wantting to talk to her are still there, but it wouldn’t be worth it and may cause more harm. Will listen to this on repeat while I get over the urge. Thank you

Thanks for your vulnerability

Thanks for your vulnerability, Janlee. I'm so glad the article and video are helping you find the strength to avoid a choice that is likely to cause you more pain. 

I contacted APs for good reason

I contacted all 4 of the affair partners, each in separate instances of infidelity. My boyfriend was a love addict, it took time to discover. He would fall in love and be disposed to continue multiple relationships until they would crash into reality. He didn't want to give anyone up. Somehow he imagined himself innocent of doing anything wrong, even as he had to lie to keep multiple women in the dark. When discovered, he would apologize apparently sincerely and then "move on," since he instantly was not the person who did that anymore. Then, he'd meet someone somewhere and "innocently" fall in love as if fated to do so. The self deception of this man was almost as excessive as the deception of the women involved.

Because of this, it was very clear to me that the other women were almost certainly unaware. When I discovered each one, I gave him the chance to tell them and come clean or I would do it. He did not take the opportunity even once to do so. This is why it was very important for me to tell them.

It was sufficient to message all but one, who I requested to meet with us. This last one imagined herself as liberating him to have an open relationship. In that case it was important that we see each other as undeniably real people. I needed each to be clear that each of us could choose for our own selves what to do, but there would be no choice that would involve me accepting anything other than either being the only woman or separating from him.

He chose me, but clearly fidelity is not something I can ever feel secure about. I only regret that I allowed this last woman to see our children, in terms of initiating communication.

I can understand how contact with an AP could turn into a fight or just twist the emotions up tighter. Still, I felt a great responsibly. When a man lies to women in order to keep them loving him and having sex, that is abusive and basically rape. The women have their choice taken away when important information is concealed. I would never have consented to have a relationship knowing that there were other women, and 3 of the 4 other women felt the same.

And, I'm still trying to repair the relationship and keep my family together, as crazy as that is. Nobody can decide for anyone else whether repair is worth committing to, and I'm not totally confident on that myself. The other women are all now married, except the one that wanted to liberate him from me, so I know they value fidelity and monogamy as much as I do. May that they have never had this kind of experience again.

What a courageous thing to do

What a courageous thing to do. That couldn't have been easy for you. Thank you for giving us a glimpse of how to handle impossibliy hard situations with grace.

Glad I communicated with them

I think this came up before. In retrospect, I am so glad I contacted the betrayal objects, as well as some of their spouses (not all were married). But, never in a fit of rage or anger, and never using foul language or name-calling. The spouses who were betrayed were all very appreciative and actually shared info with me. It was useful and helpful all around. I do not regret doing so, and for me, it was all helpful. Personally, I would have been so appreciative if someone would have contacted me a decade or three earlier to let me know my spouse was betraying me. Each situation is unique. Think through your situation carefully. For me, it was the right choice.

Thank you for sharing with us

Thank you for sharing with us, Alicita. You're right, each situation is unique and while it may not be a good idea as a general rule, it's not true across the board. It's important to take our situation, as well as our own personality and emotional state into consideration when making those kinds of decisions. 

💯

I agree however the choice was removed from me when the AP sought ME out. At MY church. I had no idea she was there, went to the bathroom and she followed me in. We washed our hands at the same time and I knew who she was so I reached out to introduce myself. She was shaking and scared and I was cool. As. A. Cucumber. I told her I had been praying for her and her kids (true.). She tried to "apologize". She deflected and blamed my husband completely. Told me lies to try to sabotage our healing. She kept following me and I kept walking away saying I wished her the best (also true.). The Holy Spirit gave me the peace that surpasses understanding and I have never been so proud of how I carried myself. She was not expecting the grace, compassion and forgiveness and you could see it on her face that it threw her off. I agree with the article though. You'll never get what you deserve from an AP. Only heartache.

Wow, Patti! That is an

Wow, Patti! That is an incredible testament to the power of the Holy Spirit within us. You demonstrated so much strength and dignity. Good for you.

his AP contacted me!

I found out about his affair while driving a 7 hour trip to see my adult children. Rather than face the music he left the house (with our 2 dogs) to stay with her. I came home to an empty house and had no clue what, why, where, when or with who. I wanted answers but I knew better than to blow up his phone - people answer a call when they choose and less likely because it rings a million times, besides I was humiliated enough. His AP was unusually cruel - she sent a picture of the two of them looking so happy without a care in the world. The caption read "This might motivate you to leave him the f*&^ alone and move on". I did not respond yet she wasn't done. She drunk called me, forwarded text conversations between the two of them and made a Facebook campaign about how he left me and they are now an item. I had so much I wanted to fire back with, but because I reached out to programs like this and really leaned in I was able to make what was the right decision for me. I used my anger (really rage) and hurt in a different way. I wrote an "I HATE YOU because" letter to his AP with no intention of her ever seeing it. I was able to process my out of control emotions and identify all the ways I had been unjustly betrayed while maintaining my dignity. It did give me slight satisfaction that she felt so threatened by me she had to go out of her way to declare their true love. btw he did come home - that part of the journey is for another story.

Wow, Raelynn! Thanks for

Wow, Raelynn! Thanks for sharing some of your story with us It's just incredible that you were able maintain your composure and conduct yourself in a way you could be proud of, especially in the midst of such cruelty. Great job! It's so important to remember that another person's actions don't negate our good character. How inspiring for all of us. Thanks again!

The betrayed should know

It is my opinion that if you find out your spouse is betraying you with someone...you should let the affair partners spouse know. Wouldn't you like to know?

I believe it would be cruel to not tell. It would leave the Affair partners spouse believing something that is not true in their relationship and if the affair partner does not tell their spouse then someone else should tell them so they have the truth. Would you not want the truth in your relationship?

You as the betrayed telling the other spouse may not get the response you hope for, but at least the other spouse knows and they can deal with it how they need to...otherwise they may have to endure another affair later.

What type of affair was it?

Our free Affair Analyzer provides you with insights about your unique situation and gives you a personalized plan of action.
Take the Affair Analyzer

Free Surviving Infidelity Bootcamp

Our experts designed this step-by-step guide to help you survive infidelity. Be intentional with your healing with this free 7-day bootcamp.
head-silhouette
 
I would highly recommend giving this a try.
 
-D, Texas