Rick Reynolds, LCSW
by Rick Reynolds, LCSW
Founder & President, Affair Recovery

Will I Ever Feel Chosen?

In the third grade, I was placed in leg braces. For the first time in my young life, I felt different—isolated, set apart, and alone. The worst part of my new reality came each day at recess with the dreaded game of kickball. Mrs. Anderson would appoint team captains who would take turns selecting team members. I vividly recall standing there, eagerly hoping to be picked, only to be chosen last, every time.

Many of us carry echoes from the past. Perhaps you remember a time, like in third grade, feeling awkward or different—maybe it was braces, or orthopedic shoes, or just not fitting the mold. Maybe you have memories like mine of being on the playground, waiting and hoping to be picked for the team, only to find yourself chosen last or not at all. That sting of feeling unchosen creates a wave of shame, and raises the question: "Will I ever be first? Will I ever belong? Will I ever truly be chosen?"

While a childhood kickball game might seem like a sprinkler compared to the hurricane of infidelity, the emotional equivalence can be profound. Betrayal often rips open those same deep wounds that come from the feeling of not being chosen, the crushing weight of shame, and the terrifying fear of irreparable disconnection. This isn't just about the present event; it's often connected to what psychologists call developmental trauma. They are situations where, perhaps even subtly, our core needs felt unmet, and we learned to disconnect from ourselves and internalize the shame in order to maintain vital connections, even unhealthy ones.

Understanding the Why Empowers Your What Now

Recognizing these deeper roots isn't about getting stuck in the past or blaming yourself. It's about understanding why betrayal cuts so deep, touching those fundamental human needs for safety, connection, and worthiness.

And here's the crucial part: This understanding is the key to reclaiming your power in the present.

The pain you feel is valid, immense, and real. But your healing journey forward is yours to direct. Regardless of the choices your spouse made (or is still making), you can choose to begin your personal healing journey today. You don't have to know your future to step into the future. You have the agency to navigate your pain, rebuild your sense of self, and choose your path forward. You get to decide how you heal!

Take Your First Step Towards Healing with Harboring Hope

Making sense of this emotional hurricane alone is overwhelming. That's why we created Harboring Hope. It is Affair Recovery's dedicated online course specifically designed for betrayed spouses like you.

It provides:

  • Tools to understand and process your trauma.
  • Guidance for navigating intense emotions like grief, anger, and confusion.
  • Help in ending codependent tendencies.
  • Strategies to rebuild your self-worth and regain your footing.
  • A supportive framework to help you anchor yourself and reclaim your agency, no matter what your spouse decides.

Navigating the Path Together

For couples where both partners are committed to the difficult work of rebuilding trust and understanding the deep impact of the affair, Affair Recovery offers structured support:

  • EMS Weekend: An intensive, in-person weekend retreat for couples seeking breakthrough and recovery.
  • EMS Online: A flexible, comprehensive online program guiding couples through the recovery process from home.

The pain of betrayal can feel like it defines you, always threatening to dredge up feelings you thought were long buried. But you are more than the pain you are feeling! Understanding its roots can be the first step toward reclaiming your narrative and recognizing your inherent worth. You have the strength to heal, and we are here to help.

With hope and support,
The Affair Recovery Team

Sections: 

RL_Category: 

RL_Media Type: 

Add New Comment:

Comments

I feel like this article is

I feel like this article is unhelpful in that it appears to suggest the worst pain in infidelity is that it awakens childhood pains. As a betrayed spouse I'd like to challenge that.
Sure, everyone I imagine will have experienced some mistakes from their parents/caregivers/community growing up. There is no perfect parent etc. But to suggest that the worst part of infidelity is that it harkens back to previous pains, is so dismissive and seems to seek to take the blame away from the betrayer. I think it is really unhelpful for betrayers to think this way.

It also seems to possibly hint at describing the betrayed as someone who had a difficult life. Which in my own experience and that of friends who have been betrayed, is not the case. We were all confident, sporty, energetic and lively people with optimistic outlooks. We didn't have a wealth of awful experiences behind us.

The worst part of the pain of infidelity for me was the fact my husband cheated, lied, stole, and fantacised constantly about people who were not me, when he had made very serious promises to me. That's what was and is painful.

The biggest pain in my experience came from the fact my ex husband didn't choose to fight and resist temptation for me, (as everyone in a relationship will face temptation at some point), and didn't choose to be honest with me about the fact I had been cheated on, and that our life was now a lie, after the fact. He then continued to live for years with me not knowing infidelity had taken place. That is utterly utterly horrific for someone to experience. The level of constant gaslighting and complete carelessness of my experience of life is horrible.

Please don't let betrayers think the majority of the trauma for the betrayed is historical. The majority, if not all, the trauma is based on the decisions and actions the betrayer took. The pain is caused by the betrayer. And usually that comes from simply selfishness, greed, insecurity etc.

Thank you for sharing your

Thank you for sharing your experience. It's so valuable to recognize that each person's story is unique, and therefore, we resonate with different things. When I was growing up, this perspective of "not being chosen" played out through perfectionism - I constantly felt like I had to be perfect, and maybe then, I'd be good enough. While much of that pressure came from family, a good amount of it was just within myself. I had a happy childhood, but I still lived my life striving to be the best student, the most compliant, the most helpful, never rocking the boat. It was a heavy weight to bear as a child, but it was all I knew.

The intense and overwhelming trauma of the infidelity reawakened those earlier feelings of needing to be perfect in order to be loved. I revisited old patterns learned as a child and struggled immensely with trying to be everything I thought my spouse wanted me to be, even blaming myself for his affairs, believing the lie that I "wasn't good enough." I stayed stuck for years. Undertanding that my worthiness was never based on anything I did or did not do, was crutial for me in recovery. I was finally able to show myself grace and relinquish the burden I'd been carrying. Once that weight was off my shoulders, it freed me up to pursue healing, which led to peace - something I don't think I had ever really known before. 

There's so much beauty in sharing our stories and learning to see things differently. Thanks again for being willing to open up.

I couldn’t agree more

Dealing with an unfaithful wife, who seem to only see the trauma as an inconvenience for her, and continues to gaslight, hide and lie is frustrating and singles lack of understanding and consideration.

Self-centered deception is very hard to see or change when only one person is trying.

What type of affair was it?

Our free Affair Analyzer provides you with insights about your unique situation and gives you a personalized plan of action.
Take the Affair Analyzer

Free Surviving Infidelity Bootcamp

Our experts designed this step-by-step guide to help you survive infidelity. Be intentional with your healing with this free 7-day bootcamp.
head-silhouette
 
I would highly recommend giving this a try.
 
-D, Texas